Summers Cay

Summers Cay

Thonotosassa, Hillsborough County, FL

3

For Sale

0

Pending

$425,000

Median Price

$212

Per SqFt

149

Avg Days

2,015

Avg SqFt

4

Sold 2yr

About Summers Cay

Summers Cay is a residential community in Thonotosassa, Hillsborough County, Florida. Homes were built between 2022 and 2023, offering 3+ bedrooms and 2+ bathrooms with an average of 2,015 square feet of living space. The median sold price is $425,000 at $212 per square foot. Homes typically sell in 149 days. Over the past two years, 4 properties have sold, with prices ranging from $380,000 to $470,000. 100% have a garage. The community has an HOA with fees averaging $126 monthly. Annual property taxes average $6,101.

Built: 2022–2023
Bedrooms: 3+
Bathrooms: 2+
Pool: 0% of homes
Garage: 100%
Avg Tax: $6,101/yr
HOA: $126 monthly
Price Range: $380,000–$470,000

Walk Score

walk scoretransit scorebike score

Scores by Walk Score

All Listings (3)

FOR SALE

$457,000

9553 Summers Cay Circle, Thonotosassa, FL, 33592

4 bd2.00 ba2150 sqft
FOR SALE

$450,000

9644 Summers Cay Circle, Thonotosassa, FL, 33592

4 bd3.00 ba2416 sqft
FOR SALE

$369,000

9547 Summers Cay Circle, Thonotosassa, FL, 33592

3 bd2.00 ba1447 sqft

Recently Sold (4)

SOLD

$470,000

9586 Summers Cay Circle, Thonotosassa, FL, 33592

5 bd3.00 ba2416 sqft
SOLD

$450,000

9647 Summers Cay Circle, Thonotosassa, FL, 33592

3 bd2.00 ba2150 sqft
SOLD

$410,000

9661 Summers Cay Circle, Thonotosassa, FL, 33592

4 bd2.00 ba1844 sqft
SOLD

$380,000

9512 Summers Cay Circle, Thonotosassa, FL, 33592

3 bd2.00 ba1650 sqft

Market Trends

Q3 - 2025
$410,000
1
Q4 - 2025
$450,000
1
Q2 - 2026
$425,000
2
QuarterSalesAvg Price$/SqFt
Q2 - 20262$425,000$212
Q4 - 20251$450,000$209
Q3 - 20251$410,000$222

Frequently Asked Questions

Similar Communities Nearby

Eastfield Slopes A Condo

9 listings · Thonotosassa

Oakmont Reserve

6 listings · Thonotosassa

Evergreen

52 listings · Thonotosassa

Williams Pointe

11 listings · Seffner

Jefferson Estates

10 listings · Thonotosassa

Toulon-phase

7 listings · Seffner

Interested in Summers Cay?

Talk to Liz Piedra, your Hillsborough County expert.

Call (727) 888-8998Message

All Properties · Hillsborough County · Thonotosassa, FL · Home Value · About Us