Island Cay

Island Cay

Apollo Beach, Hillsborough County, FL · Gated Community

1

For Sale

0

Pending

$795,000

Median Price

$396

Per SqFt

531

Avg Days

2,811

Avg SqFt

17

Sold 2yr

About Island Cay

Island Cay is a gated residential community in Apollo Beach, Hillsborough County, Florida. Homes were built between 1996 and 2011, offering 3+ bedrooms and 3+ bathrooms with an average of 2,811 square feet of living space. The median sold price is $795,000 at $396 per square foot. Homes typically sell in 531 days. Over the past two years, 17 properties have sold, with prices ranging from $795,000 to $795,000. 89% of homes include a private pool and 75% have a garage. The community has an HOA with fees averaging $368 annually. Community amenities include Gated, Fence Restrictions, Playground, Tennis Court(s). Annual property taxes average $5,495.

Built: 1996–2011
Bedrooms: 3+
Bathrooms: 3+
Pool: 89% of homes
Garage: 75%
Avg Tax: $5,495/yr
HOA: $368 annually
Price Range: $795,000–$795,000

Amenities

GatedFence RestrictionsPlaygroundTennis Court(s)

Walk Score

walk scoretransit scorebike score

Scores by Walk Score

All Listings (1)

FOR SALE

$1,400,000

416 Island Cay Way, Apollo Beach, FL, 33572

4 bd3.00 ba3028 sqft

Recently Sold (17)

SOLD

$795,000

424 Island Cay Way, Apollo Beach, FL, 33572

3 bd2.00 ba2007 sqft
SOLD

$625,000

419 Island Cay Way, Apollo Beach, FL, 33572

3 bd2.00 ba2032 sqft
SOLD

$240,000

421 Island Cay Way, Apollo Beach, FL, 33572

3 bd3.00 ba2284 sqft
SOLD

$855,000

432 Island Cay Way, Apollo Beach, FL, 33572

5 bd6.00 ba4290 sqft
SOLD

$590,000

420 Island Cay Way, Apollo Beach, FL, 33572

5 bd4.00 ba3350 sqft
SOLD

$375,000

427 Island Cay Way, Apollo Beach, FL, 33572

4 bd3.00 ba2761 sqft

Market Trends

Q2 - 2017
$722,500
2
Q4 - 2017
$240,000
1
Q3 - 2020
$470,000
1
Q3 - 2021
$890,000
1
Q1 - 2022
$1,060,000
1
Q3 - 2023
$625,000
1
Q1 - 2025
$695,000
1
Q4 - 2026
$795,000
1
QuarterSalesAvg Price$/SqFt
Q4 - 20261$795,000$396
Q1 - 20251$695,000$337
Q3 - 20231$625,000$308
Q1 - 20221$1,060,000$350
Q3 - 20211$890,000$257
Q3 - 20201$470,000$151
Q4 - 20171$240,000$105
Q2 - 20172$722,500$188

Frequently Asked Questions

Similar Communities Nearby

Bimini Bay

44 listings · Apollo Beach

Island Walk Ph I

5 listings · Apollo Beach

Apollo Beach Pt

45 listings · Apollo Beach

Apollo Beach Unit One Pt One

85 listings · Apollo Beach

Hemingway Estates-a

22 listings · Apollo Beach

Caribbean Isles Residential Co

105 listings · Apollo Beach

Interested in Island Cay?

Talk to Liz Piedra, your Hillsborough County expert.

Call (727) 888-8998Message

All Properties · Hillsborough County · Apollo Beach, FL · Home Value · About Us

Home Value