What is the average home price in Carrollwood Key?

The average sold price in Carrollwood Key is $239,986, with homes ranging from $219,900 to $269,000. The average price per square foot is $207.

How many homes are for sale in Carrollwood Key?

There are currently 0 homes for sale and 1 under contract in Carrollwood Key, Tampa, FL.

Does Carrollwood Key have an HOA?

Yes. The HOA fee averages $324 monthly.

How long do homes take to sell in Carrollwood Key?

Homes in Carrollwood Key average 26 days on market. 7 homes have sold in the past two years.

What size are homes in Carrollwood Key?

Homes range from 1,152 to 1,184 sqft, averaging 1,161 sqft with 2+ bedrooms and 2+ bathrooms.

Properties/Hillsborough County/Carrollwood Key

Carrollwood Key

Q: What neighborhoods are in Carrollwood Key?

Carrollwood Key is a residential community in Tampa.

Tampa, Hillsborough County, FL

For Sale

Pending

$245,000

Median Price

$207

Per SqFt

Avg Days

1,161

Avg SqFt

Sold 2yr

About Carrollwood Key

Carrollwood Key is a residential community in Tampa, Hillsborough County, Florida. Homes were built between 1996 and 1996, offering 2+ bedrooms and 2+ bathrooms with an average of 1,161 square feet of living space. The median sold price is $245,000 at $207 per square foot. Homes typically sell in 26 days. Over the past two years, 7 properties have sold, with prices ranging from $219,900 to $269,000. The community has an HOA with fees averaging $324 monthly. Annual property taxes average $2,187.

Built: 1996–1996

Bedrooms: 2+

Bathrooms: 2+

Pool: 0% of homes

Garage: 0%

Avg Tax: $2,187/yr

HOA: $324 monthly

Price Range: $219,900–$269,000

View Tampa Market Report →

All Listings (1)

PENDING

$229,900

11310 Cayman Key Avenue, Tampa, FL, 33624

2 bd2.00 ba1152 sqft

Recently Sold (7)

SOLD

$269,000

5516 Carrollwood Key Drive, Tampa, FL, 33624

2 bd3.00 ba1184 sqft

SOLD

$256,000

5452 Carrollwood Key Drive, Tampa, FL, 33624

2 bd3.00 ba1184 sqft

SOLD

$250,000

5502 Carrollwood Key Drive, Tampa, FL, 33624

2 bd2.00 ba1152 sqft

SOLD

$245,000

5546 Carrollwood Key Drive, Tampa, FL, 33624

2 bd3.00 ba1152 sqft

SOLD

$220,000

11304 Cayman Key Avenue, Unit 2, Tampa, FL, 33624

2 bd3.00 ba1152 sqft

SOLD

$220,000

11336 Cayman Key Avenue, Tampa, FL, 33624

2 bd2.00 ba1152 sqft

Market Trends

Q3 - 2024

$245,000

Q4 - 2024

$262,500

Q2 - 2025

$220,000

Q3 - 2025

$229,967

Quarter	Sales	Avg Price	$/SqFt
Q3 - 2025	3	$229,967	$200
Q2 - 2025	1	$220,000	$191
Q4 - 2024	2	$262,500	$222
Q3 - 2024	1	$245,000	$213

Frequently Asked Questions

Similar Communities Nearby

Unplatted

630 listings · Plant City

Waterset

582 listings · Apollo Beach

Unplatted

468 listings · Tampa

Sun City Center

424 listings · Sun City Center

Sun City Center &

424 listings · Sun City Center

Balm Grove

374 listings · Wimauma

Interested in Carrollwood Key?

Talk to Liz Piedra, your Hillsborough County expert.

Call (727) 888-8998 Message

All Properties · Hillsborough County · Tampa, FL · Home Value · About Us